Blog
Social
Revolutionizing Recruitment: Story is the New Sales Pitch
I have been on hundreds of school tours over the years, but one particular tour still stands out to me. The admissions director knew her school incredibly well, and as we walked the campus, she talked almost nonstop. She shared program details, statistics, accomplishments, facilities, and just about everything she thought I needed to know.
There was only one problem: I could barely get a word in.
The information was not wrong. In fact, much of it was impressive. But the visit felt more like a presentation than a conversation, and after a while, all of the facts started to blend together. That experience reminded me of something I have seen repeatedly in admissions and marketing. Schools often believe that if they can simply tell families enough about the school, parents will be persuaded.
But information alone is rarely what moves a family.
In the previous article in this series, I wrote that experience is the new differentiator. A thoughtfully designed admissions experience helps families feel welcomed, known, and confident. But what gives that experience meaning and helps a parent remember your school after visiting several others?
Stories.
That leads to Rule #3 in my Revolutionizing Recruitment framework:
Story Is the New Sales Pitch
Storytelling has always mattered. That is not new. What has changed is how essential story has become in a world where parents already have access to more information than they could possibly consume.
Your website can tell parents about your student-teacher ratio, academic programs, athletics, fine arts, facilities, and college acceptances. AI can summarize many of those same facts in seconds. Parents can find information about your school more easily than ever before.
What they need from you is meaning.
Facts Inform. Stories Inspire.
Schools naturally communicate facts. We talk about test scores, faculty credentials, class sizes, facilities, college acceptances, programs, awards, and outcomes. Those facts matter, and parents need them. The problem comes when we mistake information for persuasion.
A fact can tell a parent what your school has. A story can help that parent understand what your school does in the life of a child.
A school might tell a prospective family that it offers small class sizes. A story about the teacher who noticed a struggling student and helped that child regain confidence demonstrates what those small classes can actually mean. A school might describe an outstanding fine arts program, but a story about a quiet student who discovered a gift on stage helps a parent understand why that program matters.
The same is true with college outcomes. A list of acceptances may be impressive, but the story of a senior who discovered a sense of purpose and found the right next step brings the outcome to life.
Facts inform. Stories inspire.
Why We Remember Stories
One of the stories I shared during my FACTS Elevate keynote involved my son Benjamin and one of our favorite Disney attractions, Rock ‘n’ Roller Coaster (now starring the Muppets).
When Ben was finally tall enough to ride it, he was excited. He had walked through the queue with me, enjoyed the Aerosmith theme, and was ready for the experience until we reached the point where he could actually see the coaster launch.
If you have ridden Rock ‘n’ Roller Coaster, you know the moment. You hear the countdown, and then the car takes off incredibly fast. Ben watched it happen and his eyes got very big. Suddenly, all of that excitement began turning into anxiety.
As we moved closer to boarding, he became more nervous. Once we were seated and the overhead restraint came down, I could see tears beginning to well up in his eyes. He knew what was coming, and at that point there was no turning back. I tried to reassure him that he was going to be okay and that he would love it.
Then came the countdown and the launch.
Within seconds, the screaming changed. He was no longer screaming because he was terrified. He was screaming because he was having the time of his life. His fear had turned into excitement.
I could give you all kinds of facts about that ride, but those are probably not what you would remember. You are much more likely to remember the little boy who was terrified before the launch and ecstatic seconds later.
That is the power of story. It creates emotion, makes meaning, and helps us remember. The same principle applies when prospective parents are trying to understand your school.
Parents Are Looking for Transformation
Parents are not primarily interested in hearing your school’s story. They are trying to understand the story their child could experience at your school.
They want to know what might happen if their child becomes part of your community. Will their child gain confidence? Will they discover a gift? Will they find friends and a place to belong? Will they be challenged academically? Will they find adults who know them, care about them, and believe in them?
Those questions are answered through stories of transformation.
Think about the shy student who finally found a voice, the struggling reader who experienced success, the middle school student who found a place to belong, the athlete who learned leadership, or the senior who discovered a calling. Every school has stories like these.
The question is whether you are telling them.
Too often, schools communicate programs without communicating impact. They describe what happens in the classroom without showing what happens in the life of a student. Your mission becomes much more powerful when parents can see it through the experience of a real person.
Turn the Tour Into a Conversation
This is one of the reasons campus visits matter so much. A good tour is not an opportunity for the admissions director to demonstrate everything they know about the school. It is an opportunity to understand the family well enough to know what will matter most to them.
That requires listening.
Before launching into programs and statistics, ask questions. What brought this family to your school? What are they looking for? What is important to their child? What are they hoping will be different? What concerns do they have?
Those answers should shape the conversation and the stories you choose to tell.
If a child loves theater, a performing arts story suddenly becomes more relevant. If a parent is concerned about whether a shy child will make friends, a story about belonging may be exactly what they need to hear. If the family is searching for greater academic challenge, share a story that demonstrates what that challenge looks like in the life of a student.
You do not need to tell every story.
Tell the right story.
Create Story Stops
Several years ago, I was working with Pacifica Christian High School in Santa Monica, California. Head of School Jim Knight took me around campus, and I noticed something about the way he gave the tour. He would stop at visual displays throughout the school and tell the story behind the photograph.
He was not simply pointing out a hallway or describing a program. He was using the environment as a prompt to talk about real students and real experiences. What made the approach especially effective was that he had choices. He did not have to tell the same story to every family. He could choose a story that connected with the person standing in front of him.
That experience led me to begin talking about what I call Story Stops.
A Story Stop is an intentional place during a campus visit where you pause and tell a story that brings the mission of the school to life. It might be a Portrait of a Graduate display where you explain who you hope students will become. It could be a college acceptance board that allows you to share the journey of a particular graduate. It might be an athletics display, a historical timeline, an art installation, or a photograph from a student trip.
The display itself is not the point. It simply gives the tour guide an opportunity to stop and tell a meaningful story.
Your Campus Is Already Full of Stories
One of the schools I have worked with, The Woodlands Christian Academy in Texas, has invested significantly in environmental branding throughout its campus. Those displays provide natural opportunities for admissions staff to pause and communicate what the school values and what students experience.
But you do not need an expensive branding project to begin using this idea. Your campus is already full of stories. Your classrooms, athletic fields, theater, chapel, college counseling office, and hallways all provide opportunities to talk about students and the impact of your school.
The bigger question is whether the people giving your tours know those stories well enough to tell them.
That requires intentionality. Admissions staff need to collect stories. Teachers and coaches need to share them. School leaders should know which stories best illustrate the mission, and those stories need to evolve as new students and new experiences become part of the school community.
Storytelling Should Continue Online
Storytelling should not stop when the tour ends. In many cases, prospective parents will encounter your stories online before they ever visit campus.
This is where many school websites miss an opportunity. Too often, the website becomes an online version of the viewbook. We describe programs, list features, post announcements, and provide information. All of that has a place, but a website should also help prospective parents experience the people behind those programs.
One school I have worked with, Westminster Catawba Christian School in Rock Hill, South Carolina, has intentionally incorporated stories into its website. Prospective families can learn about parents, students, faculty members, and others who are part of the school community. Those stories help bring the school to life.
The same approach can be used through social media, video, email, and other communication channels. A classroom moment can become a story. A student accomplishment can become a story. A faculty member’s impact can become a story.
The goal is not simply to create more content. The goal is to help parents see your mission in action.
Make the Student the Hero
There is another important distinction in school storytelling. The school should not always be the hero.
We naturally want to talk about how great our programs, faculty, facilities, and results are. But the story becomes much more compelling when the student is at the center.
Instead of simply saying, “We have an outstanding reading program,” tell the story of the student who arrived believing she was not a good reader and discovered, through the support of a teacher, that she could succeed. Instead of saying, “We provide individual attention,” share the story of the teacher who noticed that something had changed with a student and took the time to find out why.
The program matters. The teacher matters. The school matters. But the transformation is what parents remember.
Your school is the guide. The student is the hero.
Stories Become Word of Mouth
Story also connects directly back to Rule #1: relationships are the new marketing. Your parents are some of your most influential storytellers, and they are unlikely to sit at a neighborhood gathering and repeat your student-teacher ratio or recite the talking points from your latest advertising campaign.
They will tell the story of what happened to their child.
They will talk about the teacher who made a difference, the coach who believed in their student, the administrator who responded during a difficult season, or the way their child changed after becoming part of the school.
Over time, those stories become your reputation.
That is why the better question is not, “How do we get parents to talk about us?” It is, “Are we creating experiences and transformations worth talking about?”
Questions for School Leaders
As you think about storytelling at your school, take a fresh look at the way you communicate with prospective families. What stories do they hear during a campus visit? Do your admissions staff know the stories that best illustrate your mission, and are they listening well enough to know which stories will connect with each family?
Look at your campus as well. Where are the natural Story Stops? Where could someone pause and say, “Let me tell you about the student behind this”?
Then look at your website and social media. Are you primarily communicating information, or are you regularly showing how your school is making a difference in the lives of real students?
Perhaps the most revealing question is this:
If you removed all of the facts and statistics from your campus tour tomorrow, what stories would be left?
Help Parents Imagine What Is Possible
Parents need facts. They need to understand your academics, tuition, programs, outcomes, and approach, and schools should communicate those things clearly. But facts alone rarely create the picture in a parent’s mind of what could happen to their child.
Somewhere in your school today, a student is gaining confidence, overcoming a challenge, discovering a gift, finding belonging, or becoming someone their parents once only hoped they could become. Those are not simply nice stories to share on social media. They are your mission coming to life.
Prospective parents need to hear those stories because, underneath all of their questions about programs, tuition, and academics, they are trying to answer something much more personal:
Could that be my child?
Facts tell families what your school offers. Stories help them imagine what is possible for their child.
